More Skilled, Hopkins Or Jose Napoles?

[Perfect Plex]

???
???
???

[wmute]

That's a tough one. I think Hopkins might have had a slightly more complete set of tricks. But Napoles sharpened his tools more. I don't know.

[cooper5]

Though I have a rep of voting old school I found myself voting for Hopkins here.

[Silencers]

Maybe Hopkins but Napoles' were much easier on the eyes.

[StarshipTrooper]

I tend to think it's a wash. A bit of an apples and oranges comparison because they were both incredibly skilled but in different ways. wmute is most likely correct in his assesment that Hopkins had the greater breadth of skills while Napoles had the greater depth.

Poet

[rsf]

Maybe Hopkins but Napoles' were much easier on the eyes.

yeah maybe hopkins but napoles much easier to watch

[McGoorty]

yeah maybe hopkins but napoles much easier to watch

I voted for Napoles,..... Jose Napoles,... now there was a WW.

[NChristo]

Wouldn't like to choose one over the other, although if I had to pick one it'd probably be Napoles.

[gatorDelux]

i say its equal

but napoles has better physical gifts

he was slicker IMO

[goblin213]

Defensively-Hopkins
Offensively-Napoles