Danny Garcia vs Kell Brook, who takes it?

[Hype job]

Come on man that's not true. Brook hasn't shown he can beat a good fighter. Watch how easy keith beats porter

^

This right here y'all.

[boliodogs]

Garcia showed against Guerrero that he is not that good at least in my opinion. He just barely beat Guerrero with his more accurate punching. Guerrero chased him all fight and was never badly hurt. Garcia probably loses to Brook, Porter, Thurman, Pacquiao or Bradley. At this time I don't think of Garcia as a world champion. Guerrero screamed bloody murder over the loss to Garcia. Guerrero had no complaints over his loss to Thurman who clearly beat the hell out of him and dropped him and hurt him. In this case triangle theories work for me and Thurman beats Garcia as does the other top 5 welterweights. Garcia might lose a rematch with Khan except that Garcia says he wants the Thurman vs Porter winner and not Khan. I voted Brook beats him on points since nobody has ever knocked Garcia down.

[boliodogs]

People keep doubting Garcia but he's brilliant at fighting on the back foot which he would have tondo once again.

Why shouldn't they doubt him? He is undefeated but he hasn't won impressively over a good fighter since he beat Matthysse. He wasn't impressive against Peterson or Herrera. He didn't beat Paulie the way Porter did. He had his hands full with Guerrero after Thurman slaughtered Guerrero.

[LacedUp]

According to many of the Brook faithful this is easy work for Crook, but what do you guys think?

Brook fans seem to be adamant (on here at least, from reading comments) that he walks through the best of the Welterweight division with ease, I'm not so convinced, I don't see him beating Garcia and his chin imo is questionable, I know Hearn is protecting his prized asset for the Khan fight but the atrocious competition makes me wonder if he's protecting a weak chin... vivid recollections of Senchenko making him two step come to mind.

Polls up.

Did Garcia prove himself the best of the welterweight division by beating Malignaggi and Guerrero? Hmm...

We obviously have different views on who's the top WWs in the world.

Seems like people agree with me huh? Thread backfire.

Brook would beat Garcia with ease. Too big, too strong and too accurate.

Put him in there with the likes of Pacquiao, Bradley, Thurman, Khan or Porter again and we'd see solid 50/50 fights in some cases.

Not against Garcia.

[lefthook2daliva]

Brook decisions him.

Imo, Garcia is overrated and especially @ ww.

Brook may be as well, but I think Garcia moreso.

Probably neither would accept the fight though....

[The plunger man]

Brook will beat him with his combinations and power...I can see danny getting busted up and brook also has great counter punching skills ...watch the porter fight to see....what we saw last night was a decent fighter in Garcia beat a fighter who should never get a world title shot again...Guerrero has zero boxing ability and has no B game and simply just kept plodding forward throwing a fight to the midsection and then following in with his straight left and then making it ugly and messy....Brook is a world apart from Guerrero and he would stop danny late..

[gmc_rfc_06]

Brook either stops him or takes a wide decision (117-111 range).

He's simply the better fighter. Sharper puncher, more skilled, more variation, faster, stronger, bigger....

[M Bison]

Danny only because Kell Brook is a hype job who isn't any good.

[M Bison]

Brook either stops him or takes a wide decision (117-111 range).

He's simply the better fighter. Sharper puncher, more skilled, more variation, faster, stronger, bigger....

Yes, beating guys like Jo Jo Dan, Bizier, Carson and Frankie Gavin make you a very superior fighter who has prove themselves.

[Lester Tutor]

Danny got legit power. I guess it could be something similar to Matthysse vs Postol.

Too bad Jessie Vargas ain't on PBC, and I know Vargas is wishing to be with Haymon as well as Mikey Garcia. Most Mexican American fighters want to be on American TV and follow the Haymon ride, and I think it's good for them and boxing. Huge Mexican American population in the states it only improves ratings, and that's why Haymon did it. I'd like to see Vargas vs Garcia. OH man that would be soooo good.